In my latest Beer 101 I venture into the world of the controversial and unproven. I make an assertive and unapologetic claim that beer experiences travel shock (sometimes called bottle shock). I have very little proof for such a grandiose statement, but I stand by it. When beer travels, it loses its balance and character for a short period of time. The agitation of travel jostles proteins and esters and throws everything out of whack, for at least a few days. Or so I claim.
I won’t go into the details of my argument because you can go here to read the column itself. But I will say that anecdotal evidence has led me to a practice of leaving newly arrived beer in my cellar for a few days before opening. I am talking about beer that have worked their way across the continent or the ocean. If it is a six-pack of Alley Kat from 99th Street, I don’t bother.
Personally I have found that if a beer has been mailed across several hundreds of kilometres it arrives in an agitated, unhappy state. It is harsher, less malty and exhibiting off-flavours. However after a few days those bad flavours seem to disappear and the beer presents itself in close proximity to its original profile.
I realize part of the problem is that beer is a short-lived beverage. Most regular strength beer cannot be kept more than a few months. If you ship a beer and it spends 2-4 weeks in hot trucks and cargo holds, you can expect it to be on less than its best behaviour upon arrival. Import beer needs to be evaluated with that in mind. But that is not really what I am talking about. I am referring to the short-lived effects of shipping agitation. They seem to disappear within a few days. Don’t ask me how or why. But I still did a column on it. Feel free to flame me over it.
April 22, 2011 at 9:48 AM
On the aspect of shipping time/storage time in warehouses, witness this enthusiasic young Scot’s reaction to a freshly arrived can of American beer(Ska Brewing’s Modus Hoperandi)
http://www.heavyhops.com
April 22, 2011 at 5:43 PM
I think this shock exists. I’ve had a similar experience with a local texas brew that was one of my favoriates which I drank regularly that didn’t taste the same in another state.
April 23, 2011 at 10:31 AM
Completely agree on all accounts.
For beers with a short shelf life, I usually just brew these styles myself. They better suit my tastes and the beer is even fresher than any commercial beer. That is not to say I shun all local beer, there is some great stuff that I try to sample on tap, but I typically don’t bother buying bottled versions to take home.
As for any beers that have to travel, I stick to “cellar worthy” examples only.
Beer tastes best closest to the source!
April 23, 2011 at 12:23 PM
‘…close to the source!” I had stopped into Amber’s awhile back & bought a six pack of the Kenmount Road Chocolate Stout just minutes after it was bottled. And I might add, just a short distance from home.
April 23, 2011 at 1:56 PM
I have never really thought of this but after reading I will definitely be sure to try a couple taste tests. I also wonder if there has been any research into determining if this is true? As you say, you are mostly basing this on anecdotal evidence. In general experience proteins are susceptible to change on physical agitation but I find it hard to believe the mellow agitation of simple transport would cause a large amount of denaturation or aggregation of said proteins. The small molecules (esters) are much hardier than the proteins and I find it hard to fathom a great amount of degradation based only on physical agitation, time however is a much larger factor (why beer goes bad as mentioned). This has piqued my interest and I am excited to look more into it.
April 25, 2011 at 8:17 AM
I’ve often wondered how much “That beer tasted totally different when I had it back in [insert country/city name here]!” can be to attributed age or bottle shock; or simply the fact that our taste buds are affected by experiences as well as flavours: the Munich Dunkel that I drank beside the oompah band in the Hofbrauhaus tastes completely different than the Dunkel I drank in my house last week.